Chapter 11: The Discovery Call
The discovery call is where deals are won or lost. Your goal is to understand the client's situation so well that your proposal feels inevitable.
What You'll Learn
- The optimal discovery call structure
- Key questions that uncover value
- Building affirmation loops
- From discovery to proposal
Discovery Call Structure
An effective discovery call follows this sequence:
1. Build Rapport (5 minutes)
- Connect on a personal level
- Show genuine interest
- Find common ground
2. Set Expectations (2 minutes)
- Outline the purpose of the call
- Explain you'll determine fit before discussing solutions
- Get agreement on the structure
"Thanks for making time. I'd like to spend the first part understanding your situation deeply, then we can explore whether I can help and how. Sound good?"
3. Understand Current Situation (15-20 minutes)
- Ask about their business, role, responsibilities
- Explore current challenges and pain points
- Use the "5 Whys" technique to get to root causes
4. Explore Desired Future State (10-15 minutes)
- What does success look like?
- What specific outcomes would make this worthwhile?
- How would they measure success?
5. Discuss Budget and Timeline (5 minutes)
- "What kind of budget have you allocated?"
- "When do you need to see results?"
6. Confirm Fit and Next Steps (5 minutes)
- Summarize understanding and confirm accuracy
- Outline proposal timeline
- Book the follow-up call before you hang up
The Five Essential Questions
These questions help reveal true value potential:
1. "What's at stake?"
Reveals the real business impact and urgency.
2. "What have you tried before, and why didn't it work?"
Shows sophistication and past investment.
3. "Who else in the organization cares about this issue?"
Identifies stakeholders and potential champions.
4. "What would make this project an overwhelming success?"
Defines success criteria in their terms.
5. "What would that be worth to you?"
Helps them frame value in financial terms.
Questions That Uncover Value
Understanding the Problem
| Question | What You Learn |
|---|---|
| "What happens if this doesn't get solved?" | Consequences and urgency |
| "How long has this been a problem?" | Whether it's acute or chronic |
| "Why is this a priority now?" | What's driving the timeline |
| "How is this affecting the team?" | Personal and emotional stakes |
Understanding the Business
| Question | What You Learn |
|---|---|
| "What does success look like in 6 months?" | Their definition of outcomes |
| "How would you measure success?" | KPIs they care about |
| "What's your timeline for addressing this?" | Urgency level |
| "What would solving this unlock?" | Downstream opportunities |
Understanding the Buying Process
| Question | What You Learn |
|---|---|
| "Who else needs to be involved in this decision?" | Decision-makers and influencers |
| "What's your budget range for solving this?" | Investment capacity |
| "How have you made decisions like this before?" | Process and preferences |
| "What would stop this from moving forward?" | Potential blockers |
Building Affirmation Loops
Don't wait until the end to confirm understanding. Create affirmation loops throughout:
The Technique
After sharing an insight or approach:
"So far you've seen how this could help with X. How does that play out in your company?"
"Do you see this as valuable for your team?"
"What about this approach resonates most with your situation?"
Why It Works
When clients articulate value in their own words, they: - Reinforce their own understanding - Commit psychologically to the approach - Are more likely to agree to pricing - Give you language to use in the proposal
The 5 Whys Technique
When clients describe a problem, dig deeper:
Surface problem: "We need better AI"
Why? "Our current system isn't accurate enough"
Why? "We're getting complaints from users"
Why? "They're making decisions on bad data"
Why? "It's costing them money"
Why? "Our churn rate is increasing"
Root problem: Churn is increasing due to data quality issues.
Now you can price against churn reduction, not "better AI."
Recording and Transcription
Always record discovery calls (with permission):
Benefits
- Generate proposal drafts using AI
- Capture client's exact language
- Review what you missed
- Extract content ideas
The Ask
"Do you mind if I record this call? It helps me make sure I capture everything accurately for the proposal."
Most clients agree. If they don't, take detailed notes.
Using Transcripts
After the call: 1. Feed transcript to AI 2. Generate first draft proposal 3. Identify key pain points and language 4. Extract blog post ideas 5. Note objections and concerns to address
Common Discovery Mistakes
Talking Too Much
The ideal ratio is 80% listening, 20% talking.
If you're explaining your solution before understanding their problem, you've lost control of the call.
Not Going Deep Enough
Surface-level questions get surface-level answers.
| Surface Question | Deep Question |
|---|---|
| "What's the problem?" | "What happens if this doesn't get solved?" |
| "What do you need?" | "What would success look like?" |
| "What's your budget?" | "What would solving this be worth?" |
Skipping the Budget Conversation
Many consultants avoid discussing budget. This leads to: - Proposals that miss the mark - Wasted time on unqualified prospects - Awkward price negotiations later
Ask directly: "What kind of budget have you allocated for this initiative?"
Lock in the Next Meeting
At the end of every discovery call:
"It sounds like what you really need in the next couple of months is to figure out [summarize their key need]. If you can do that, you'll be able to [describe benefit]. I'm going to send you a proposal sometime next week. Are you available this time next week to jump on a call and review it?"
Why This Matters
| Without Locking | With Locking |
|---|---|
| "I'll send you a proposal" | "Let's review it together Tuesday at 2pm" |
| Days/weeks of follow-up | Single scheduled meeting |
| Momentum dies | Momentum maintained |
| They "go dark" | Clear next step |
From Discovery to Proposal
What you learn in discovery directly shapes your proposal:
| Discovery Element | Proposal Element |
|---|---|
| Their pain points | Situational assessment |
| Their words for the problem | Exact language in proposal |
| Success metrics they mentioned | Objectives section |
| What's at stake | Value/ROI framing |
| Timeline urgency | Delivery schedule |
| Budget range | Pricing tier selection |
"The quality of your proposal directly reflects the quality of your discovery process. You cannot create a compelling value-based proposal without thoroughly understanding what the client truly values."
Action Items
-
Create your question list: Write out 15-20 discovery questions organized by topic.
-
Practice the structure: Run through the 6-part call structure with a colleague or friend.
-
Set up recording: Get a transcription tool and practice asking permission.
-
Build affirmation loops: Identify 3 moments in your typical call to insert affirmation questions.
-
Always lock the next meeting: Make this non-negotiable in every discovery call.
Key Takeaways
- Structure discovery calls: rapport → expectations → current state → future state → budget → next steps
- The five essential questions reveal stakes, past attempts, stakeholders, success criteria, and value
- Build affirmation loops throughout—don't wait until the end
- Use the 5 Whys to find root problems (where the real value is)
- Listen 80%, talk 20%—discovery is about them, not you
- Record calls for proposal generation, language capture, and content ideas
- Always lock in the next meeting before hanging up